Concatenation and Discontinuity of Credentials - A review of some important but less well-known terms
اتصال و انقطاعِ اسناد- چند اہم مگر غیر معروف اصطلاحات کا جائزہ
Keywords:
Hadith, Sawab, Saheeh, Tashech, Isnad, Asahh, Ittisal, Samaa, Madar, RaviAbstract
Concatenation and Discontinuity of Isnad is a significant issue in the sciences of Hadith. It involves the complex challenges surrounding the transmission chains of Hadith, some of its complications are not less than Bab Al-Illa in their complexity and difficulty. It’s significance can be gauged by the fact that it forms a substantial portion, around one third, of the sciences of Hadith. This emphasizes the crucial role Isnads play in the examination and comprehension of Hadith. Scholars use various terms to discuss this, such as Ittisal, Irsal, Tadlees, Idrak, Liqa, Simaa, and more. Additionally, there are lesser-known terms like Al-Zaq, Tasheeh, Batr al-Faz, Akhbar, and Hadith Yahwee. In the preceding discussion, the same terms have been explained in the light of the texts of Scholars. Key words: Hadith, Ittisal, Irsal, Ilzaq, Akhbar, Alfaz, Tashech, Batr, Hadithuho Yahwi. The term "Tasheeh" in light of the usages of previous critics. In the applications of early Hadith critics, there was no stagnation like that found among later scholars. The reason for this stagnation in terminology was the influence of Greek logic, whether conscious or unconscious, which impacted various Islamic and Arabic sciences, including Hadith. As a result, scholars of terminology aimed to provide comprehensive and restrictive definitions for each term, while scholars of Hadith focused on the intended meaning of the term when using it. This led to a broader usage of Hadith terms, such as "Sahih," which was clarified through their applications and texts.
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10513077
References
(1) Ahmad, Elal and Marefaturejal (1/537).
(2) Abu Dawood, Questions of al-Ajri (1/433), and : al-Darimi, al-Sunan Hadith (793), Masa'il Abi Dawood (p. 428).
(3) Ibn Abi Hatim, al-Jarah wa'l-Ta'deel (1/236).
(4) Ahmad, 'Ilal wa'l-'Arif al-Rijal (3/227).
(5) Ibn Abi Hatim, al-Jarah wa'l-Ta'deel (1/239).
(6) Ibn Abi Hatim, al-Jarah wa'l-Ta'deel (1/240-241).
(7) Ahmad, al-'Ilal wa'l-Maarifa al-Rijal (1/531), (3/80), Naiz Dikhihi: Salah al-Din, Jami' al-Tahseel (p. 208), Ibn Hajar, Tahdheeb al-Tahdheeb (3/176).
(8) Martyrdom of Imam Hussain (PBUH)
(9) Ibn Abi Hatim, 'Ilal al-Hadith (1/97).
(10) Ahmad, Questions of Abu Dawood (p. 224).
(11) Ibn Abi Hatim, al-Jarah wa'l-Ta'deel (5/188), Niz Dekhihi: al-Fasuwi, Ya'qub ibn Sufyan ibn Jawan, al-Maarifa wal-Tareekh (1/718).
(12) Ahmad, Questions of Abu Dawood (p. 237).
(13) Ahmad, Issues of Abu Dawood (p. 403).
(14) Dikahi: an-Nasaa'i, al-Mujtaba (hadith no: 589), Ahmad, Questions of Abu Dawood (p. 277), al-Tabarani, al-Mu'jam al-Awsat (hadith no: 9245), Ibn 'Uday, al-Kamil fi Da'eef al-Rijal (4/1564), al-Khatib, Tareekh Baghdad (9/193), (4/278).
(15) Ahmad, Ills and Knowledge of Men (1/53-6).
(16) المزي، تهذيب الكمال (10/132).
(17) Ibn al-Madani, al-Ilal (p. 63).
(18) Al-Hakim, Knowledge of Hadith Sciences (p. 107).
(19) الخطيب، تاريخ بغداد (5/82).
(20) ابن حجر، تهذيب التهذيب (9/305 - 307).
(21) م: "مسائل أبي داود" (ص 389)، "سؤالات أبي داود" (ص 231)، "العلل ومعرفة الرجال" (3/435)، "مسائل إسحاق" (2/220) ، "علل ابن المديني" (ص 51، 54، 57)، "المعرفة والتاريخ" (2/52)، "التمهيد" (1/49)، "تهذيب الكمال" (4/197)، "جامع التحصيل" (ص 173)، "تهذيب التهذيب" (2/441)، (3/438)۔
(22) أبو زرعة، سؤالات البرذعي (ص 493).
(23) Al-Khatib, Tareekh Baghdad (12/273).
(24) Ibn Abi Hatim, al-Jarah wa'l-Ta'deel (5/368).
(25) Ibn Abi Hatim, al-Marasil (p. 192).
(26) Ibn Ammar al-Shaheed, Reasons for hadiths in Sahih Muslim (p. 136).
(27) Ahmad, Questions of Abu Dawood (p. 200).
(28) Ahmad, Elal and Marefaturejal (3/94).
(29) Ahmad, Elal and Marefaturejal (2/362).
(30) Ahmad, Elal and Marefaturijal of Men (1/295, 537), Ahmad, Masa'il Abi Dawood (p. 426), Masa'il Salih (p. 259), al-Fasuwi, Ya'qub ibn Sufyan ibn Jawan, Knowledge and History (3/171, 182), al-Batih Akhtar Ten sources of "meaning: Marasil" as the words mentioned Nihai.
(31) Ibn Abi Hatim, 'Ilal al-Hadeeth (2/292).
(32) Ibn Abi Hatim, al-Jarah wa'l-Ta'deel (1/241).
(33) Ibn Abi Hatim, al-Jarah wa'l-Ta'deel (1/236).
(34) 'Ali ibn al-Ja'ad, al-Musnad (1/8), al-Dhahabi, Sir al-'Ulam al-Nubala' (7/216).
(35) Ibn Abi Hatim, al-Jarah wa'l-Ta'deel (1/68).
(36) Ibn Abi Hatim, al-Jarah wa'l-Ta'deel (1/68).
(37) ابن حبان، المجروحين (1/227).
(38) Ibn Abi Hatim, al-Jarah wa'l-Ta'deel (2/34).
(39) العقيلي، الضعفاء الكبير (3/144).
(40) Ahmad, 'Ilal wa'l-'Arif al-Rijal (1/266).
(41) Ahmad, 'Ilal wa'l-Maarifa al-Rijal (1/266),: al-Fasuwi, al-Maarifa wal-Tareekh (2/633).
(42) الفسوي، المعرفة والتاريخ (2/633).
(43) العجلي، الثقات (1/225).
(44) Al-Khatib, Tareekh Baghdad (12/273), : Ibn Mu'in, Maarifa al-Rijal (2/76 ).
(45) Al-Fasuwi, Knowledge and History (2/633).: Ahmad, Elal and Marifaturejal - Narrated by al-Marwadhi (p. 44), Ibn Mu'in, Knowledge of Men (2/77).
(46) الخطيب، تاريخ بغداد (8/197).
(47) Ahmad, Questions of Abu Dawood (p. 199).